Long Island has traditionally been seen as a private haven for the wealthy and famous. This island, on the other hand, has a lot more to offer. In all four of its counties, you will be able to enjoy nature, arts, and the entertainment scene. But, what Long Islanders pride themselves on is their ability to take a certain dish and make it their own. We've compiled a list of some of the most iconic Long Island foods to try during your next visit.
Long Island style pizza
Of course, Long Island is not the birthplace of this wonderful, cheesy goodness we call pizza. Despite this, its eateries have taken the dish to new heights by preparing it in various ways. Iconic crusts and toppings are commonplace on Long Island. Opt for the Cold Cheese Slice at Little Vinnie's in Lake Ronkonkoma if you want to try something truly unique. You might also give your tastebuds the pleasure of trying the Pizza Network's Garlic Knot Pizza (Oakdale). Take a stroll along several Long Island streets, and we're convinced you'll come across some genuinely unique pizza varieties.
Long Island's variety of bagels
From fried egg breakfast bagels to dessert bagels, Long Island's got you covered. Many bagel shops are run by families and have a lengthy history. As a result, their recipes have been developed and modified, making them the best choice for foodies visiting Long Island. You won't be able to visit them all in one trip, but you might stand a chance if you are relocating to Long Island. Make sure to contact experts from the Long Island City area who can help speed up this process and give you more time to enjoy all the bagels the place has to offer. You'll be one step closer to calling yourself a true Long Islander.
Fresh Shucked Oysters
If you are a big fan of seafood, you are in luck! Long Island has a multitude of seafood dishes you can try out and enjoy. Because of the abundance of oyster farms, there are a plethora of eateries serving only the freshest oysters money can buy. Long Island oysters are known to be large and packed with flavor, making them a must-try. As for the sauce, each eatery has a unique recipe, so visit them with an empty stomach. If you've still got an appetite for oysters, don't worry, Long Island has an annual Oysterfest in October!
Long Island Hamburgers
While on Long Island, do not forget to try the classic American Hamburger. However, classic doesn't have to mean plain. There's no shortage of unique options on Long Island! One of the oldest and most famous places to grab yourself a hamburger you won't forget is the All-American Drive-In located in Massapequa. You can rest certain they have had many years to perfect their recipe, which they have done. If you're looking for something spicy, the Burger Shack's Burger from Hell is perfect for you. Don't worry if your food preferences do not include meat; there are plenty of meatless options for you as well.
Unique Long Island milkshakes
After you've had something salty, you will need a sweet treat. We highly suggest trying different kinds of milkshakes Long Island has to offer. One such milkshake is the Tie-Dye Milkshake by Diner by the Sea. This milkshake is flavorful and beautiful, making it a great pick-me-up, as well as a nice photo op. Burgerology's Rainbow Cookie Milkshake is another excellent choice.
Additionally, if you love American Pie but wish it was in the form of a milkshake, visit Dang BBQ and ask for the Bye Bye Miss American Pie. Simplify Valet Storage & Moving highly suggest exploring the area before relocating, and what better way to do that than with a nice milkshake in your hand? Take in all the beautiful sights around Long Island and enjoy your tasty treat.
Long Island's Croissant French Toast
If you are on the lookout for a fulfilling and iconic dessert on Long Island, look no further than the Croissant French Toast. If you are a foodie, the combination of these two dishes might be a dream come true. Although many places serve it, Maureen’s Kitchen is the one that made Croissant French Toast the delicacy it is today. You might need to arm yourself with patience when visiting Maureen's kitchen! The wait time can be pretty long, but you will be rewarded with cream cheese goodness combined with different fruits of your choosing by the end of it. Couple that with a nice cup of your favorite beverage, and you have yourself a lovely treat.
Long Island's Gourmet Pancakes
It can be challenging to compete with the classic breakfast favorite that is a fluffy mouthwatering pancake. But if you want to try something new, try Long Island's gourmet pancakes. Think of any sort of topping you would wish, and Long Island will provide just that. From S'more Pancakes, M&M Pancakes to Stuffed Pancakes, you will not be left hungry and unsatisfied. If you prefer gluten-free, vegan options, visit the Green Street Eatery in Levittown.
Long Island's healthy dessert options
Lastly, you won't have to give up your diet while on Long Island. Some of the most iconic Long Island foods come in a vegan, gluten-free, and organic form. Your taste buds, gut, and waistband will be happy if you visit a place such as the Pleasant Petites. They have a wide selection of healthy but tasty desserts to choose from. The legendary Red Velvet Snowballs are one such delight that will leave you wanting more. The Mint Chocolate Chip Snowballs are also a popular choice among guests! Although these desserts are only a few bites in size, they will satisfy your need for crunch, sweetness, and chewiness.